Inside: Minimalism encourages giving experience gifts, many of which are more expensive than a physical gift. But we forget that physical gifts can be an experience, too, one that lasts for a very long time.
As we stood in line at the local Children’s Museum with four excited kids, I got that anxious feeling. It was the same feeling I used to have when I wondered whether my carefully plotted coupon deals would work out: would the cashier look at me with that mixture of pity and annoyance as I scrambled to figure out what went wrong and why I owed $5 when it was supposed to be free?
As the line inched forward, I braced myself for disappointment. This supposedly free excursion (a fun, memory-making, ideal minimalist experience) might not work out, after all.
When you have four small children and live on one income, you’re constantly looking for free or cheap kid activities. The day prior, we browsed the local parenting website for ideas. It mentioned that Bank of America card holders could get into the local children’s museum for free that weekend. Score! We (foolishly) assumed this meant that our whole family could get in for free.
Yes, it was a stupid assumption. We know.
We made it to the front desk, and my husband pulled out his Bank of America debit card. My heart sank as the man confirmed my suspicions: the card only equaled one free admission. I had stupidly forgotten my wallet with an additional card at home. Admission for all of us would cost $25.
More on Being a One Income Family:
- 52 Ways to Save Money so You Can Stay Home
- 14 Things We Aren’t Buying to Make Ends Meet
- 11 Ways to Save Money Every Month with Very Little Effort
- How to Save Money on Groceries When Your Husband Isn’t On Board
Choosing a Physical Gift over an Experience
While I was prepared to pay the admission fee, my non-minimalist, frugal husband disagreed. After all, the museum consistently offered discounted admission once a week. To him, it just wasn’t worth the money, and eventually I acquiesced. I’m frugal too, after all. He would rather buy them a toy or a board game that they could play with for days instead of hours.
We could have paid it; we chose not to.
We walked our slightly disappointed kids back to the car, and he drove to Target. Yes, Target. That red bulls eye is probably the symbol of all things NOT minimalism.
I sat in the car with the sleeping baby, silently willing my husband not to come out with a cheap piece of junk that they would quickly lose interest in. Please, please don’t trade an experience for a piece of junk!
They came out with a new board game – one of those “8 games in 1” type of things (and a ball for the baby who loves balls). The cost? $10 less than the museum.
To further eradicate all final traces of disappointment, we drove to a free, local splash pad. As we watched them get totally soaked (in their regular clothes, no less), I sat with my questions and my own disappointment.
Experiences versus Gifts in Minimalism
You see, minimalism sold me on the belief that experiences are paramount – far more worthy of our hard-earned cash than physical gifts. Every single minimalist book and article stated the results of the same psychological study demonstrating that experiences make people happier than buying stuff.
And I bought it. Hook, line, and sinker. It sounded so awesome – and carried with the promise of not filling our house with stuff.
The problem? In my mind, these experiences often cost far more than things, at least the ones I was reading about. I heard trips, and museums, and activities, all of which can be expensive.
Yes, I know – they don’t have to be. You can find free and cheap activities. We’ve gotten pretty good at it actually.
There has only been one other experience like this one (I’m looking at you, supposedly FREE carnival in Newton. Free to walk around and watch other kids do the $5 a pop, lame rides, you mean. Grrrr.)
But in the same way that people want to keep up with the Jones’s by buying more stuff, I constantly found myself wanting to keep up with the [insert the imaginary, better off financially, minimalist family’s last name] by buying more experiences.
More on Minimalism on a Low Income:
- The Downside to Minimalism (that no one likes to talk about)
- How Minimalism Can HURT Your Budget
- 8 Tips for Decluttering on a Low Income (from someone who knows)
Physical Gifts Can Give Experiences
As I sat watching my kids, who had long since moved past their brief flash of disappointment, my husband interrupted my thoughts.
“You know, growing up, I have really fond memories of playing board games with my siblings. We did give our kids an experience, and one that has the potential to build stronger relationships and longer lasting memories than a couple of hours at a museum ever will.”
We did give our kids an experience, and one that has the potential to build stronger relationships and longer lasting memories than a couple of hours at a museum ever will.
You see, when my husband was 10 years old, his dad had a massive stroke. His mom had to quit working to care for her husband and four children. They lived on disability and unemployment and food stamps for a long, long time.
Things got better for their family. They did have the occasional trip to the shore and a local family-owned amusemtn park, but their fun experiences more often looked like gifts, and those gifts were sometimes yard sale, dollar store, and Walmart offerings.
He is frugal, but he is no minimalist. He also loves giving physical gifts to his kids.
And you know what? He was right. Since that day a few months ago, the kids learned how to play chess. They’ve played that game over and over and over again. Even our four-year-old likes to play, with lots of guidance. They built memories that probably will last a lifetime.
And those memories came from buying a physical thing, from a gift that turned into an experience.
When we finally did go to the museum on discount day, they actually knew how to play with the giant chess board…how many kids their age know how to play chess?
Am I against experiences? No. I still love giving our kids experiences, but I’ve stopped putting them on this pedestal in my mind.
And I’ve definitely stopped believing they need to be these grand, expensive things to be great gifts.
A picnic in the park? An experience.
A drive to the nearby lake? An experience.
Attending a free Home Depot build? An experience.
We are still saving for a fun (rather expensive) vacation that will hopefully happen one day. But I’ve also seen the movie Up – remember the old man and his wife breaking their savings jar again…and again, and again?
Life happens, and the grandiose experiences we plan to give our kids may not always work out. There are things like roofs to keep over heads, cars to fix, and unexpected surgeries to pay for.
That’s just life with kids and what you sign up for when you’re raising a family on one income in a two-income society.
To the Minimalist who Can’t Afford Experiences
So for every parent who has jumped on the minimalist bandwagon but can’t afford to give her children expensive experiences: take heart. I want you to know that it’s ok.
What matters more is how you see your inability to afford the expensive experiences.
Are you discontent? Disappointed? Disillusioned?
Those feelings will probably transfer to your kids.
Your kids value what you value, at least when they’re little. Do you value staying home and being with them? Give them that gift with confidence.
Right now, you’re making choices based on what you value, and it might mean trading expensive vacations and indoor playgrounds and adventure parks for more kids and a stay-at-home parent. But if you are constantly grasping for something that’s out of your reach, that will affect them far more than the lack of extraordinary experiences will.
Maybe they will complain later on about the things they never got to do. But that’s something to deal with another day.
Today, they’re still little and you know what? They really don’t know care that much at all about the indoor playground versus the [free] local park. Would they like it? Sure! But they will absolutely be o.k. if it’s a park instead.
After we finished playing at the splash pad and learned how to play chess that day, guess what my 7-year-old daughter said? “Best. Day. Ever!!”
So my conclusion about minimalist experiences? I still love the concept.
But sometimes a physical gift that provides ongoing experiences is just as good.